they were forced to read until they could read no more. And why could they read no more?
Not because they had given up the will to read, but because-
they had come to the end of the book.
Obviously this headline was a clever ploy to grab your attention. However, the facts happen to be true. This last friday at the Staunton library a group of sixth grade girls and their teacher Becky McKenzie allowed themselves to be locked into the library overnight for a read-in. Of my tween novel Coyote Summer.
I couldn't be more proud. In fact, if family matters had not necessitated my going out of state I would have locked myself in with them.
A read-in. What a great idea. How I would have loved that as a young girl. In fact, I can picture the exact space we could have used in the Morristown TN library. The new one, that is; there wasn't even room for all the books in the old library, And besides, it was kind of creepy.
I had another great encounter with a young reader this month. While I was up north, one of my 10 year old first readers brought me her edited version of my next book.
I must admit, I had not expected her mother to print it out in its final mark-up state. Nor had I expected a line by line edit and critique from a 10 year old. I kind of thought she was going to read it as a PDF and tell me if she liked it or not.
But my cousin's daughter's daughter (I have no idea what that makes her) Natalie doesn't do anything half-way. Not only did she comment, she commented on the comments. My personal favorites were a comment she made to me while we were going over her suggestions, "I don't think that comment is right. You might do it that way if this was a YA book, but not for kids my age," and of course my personal favorite,"I think the way Margo did it was better."
And - she changed the title.
Thank you, Natalie. I agree with almost all of your suggestions.
Perhaps you can suggest a read-in at your local library when the next book comes out. I'm still thinking about that title.
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Sunday, January 18, 2015
Sunday, November 16, 2014
Dear Sara Loewen . . .
(I have no idea why this showed back up here, when it was written a year ago. Oh, the mysteries of the internet . . .)
You can visit Alaska, too.
Why am I calling you dear?
I spoke to you for perhaps forty-five seconds at this year’s AWP
conference. You were manning the
University of Alaska press table when I walked up. I had no idea who you were, never heard of
your book. I’d attended a panel of
Alaskan writers that morning and was actually there to purchase someone else’s
book. I don’t remember whose now, only
that it wasn’t available and you told me I’d have to order it. I’m sure I did, perhaps I’ve read it by now,
or perhaps it’s sitting on my shelf; in
the stack of books waiting until I have
more time.
But oh, my dear dear Sara Loewen. You suggested your book, sitting on the corner of the table. You said perhaps if I enjoyed reading about
Alaska I would enjoy your book. I liked
the title, Gaining Daylight, and was
taken by the subtitle Life on Two Islands.
I spent years on an
island. I may have talked to you briefly
about that. But mostly I bought your
book because you were there, and you pointed it out, and I would’ve been
embarrassed not to buy it. It would’ve felt
somehow rude. I wouldn’t have wanted someone to walk away after I’d suggested
they buy my book.
I picked your book up last week, out of that pile of ‘to be gotten to’ books. I picked it because it was small and light, because it was short
essays that could be carried in my bag and read in waiting rooms. I had no expectations.
Dear Sara Loewen,
Your writing stuns
me. I read each essay slowly, once, and
then again. It’s been a long time since
I savored a book as much as this one.
Every image is so clear, so bright.
Every word seems to be the perfect word, the only word that could
possibly have been used to convey that idea, but that sentiment. The things you write about and at the same
time encompassing everything. I don’t
have the words to describe your words.
I’m not that good.
Dear, dear Sara Loewen.
Whether you’re
writing about salmon fishing, running your own skiff, substituting for second
grade, whether you’re telling me about the Russians encamped on Kodiak Island,
or Rose Tweed, the Bell of Kodiak during World War II, or baby humpback whales,
it feels like everything you’re saying is true and right and important, and I
want to know what you know, and I want to feel what you feel. Do you know how rare this is to a reader like
myself? Do you know how good you are?
Sara Loewen, you inscribed my copy of Gaining Daylight.
You wrote “hope you visit Alaska one day soon. You’ll love it.”
I visit Alaska. In
small, beautifully rendered, beautifully written essays. I visit Kodiak Island and Amook Island. I visit fish camps and beaches swept by fall
winds, I visit the 1890’s Russian settlements, and the Army barracks in World
War II. I visit Rose Tweed Lake. And it’s all because I happen to be in the
right place at the right time on a snowy day in Boston. And because of you, Sara Loewen.
Thank you. Truly.
Wednesday, November 12, 2014
A very roundabout review . . .
When I was in grade school my best friend was Elizabeth
Holmes. I might not have been her best friend, but I considered her
mine. I was not a kid who made a lot of
friends. Elizabeth and I wrote poetry,
and traded first and second places back and forth in contests for several years. Every year we ended up in the teachers lounge
at school, as the winners of the local spelling bee, working on memorizing
words in order to make regional or state champion. Elizabeth usually went farther than I
did. She had more determination, even at
that age.
Fast-forward about
thirty-five years. I run into Elizabeth’s
mother in our hometown when I’m visiting my father. I screw my courage up (I hate asking
questions to which I do not know the answers, because what if the answer is bad,)
and ask her how Elizabeth is doing and where she is. I get a phone number and an address in
upstate New York. I hate the phone, so I
write.
I tell her I was in the theater,
and now I am running an Inn and cooking and that I started writing poetry
again.
Not surprisingly, she is a professor. It’s that concentration thing again. And she writes poetry. In fact, she has a book of poetry out. I believe I overwhelm her with my eagerness
to connect. We don’t write again. I buy her book of poetry.
Jump forward ten years.
I have several prize chapbooks and a book of poetry published. I look Elizabeth up on that amazing new thing
called the Internet. She now has two
books of poetry.
Elizabeth has married a professor of English. I have married a professor of English. Both of our professors are creative writers.
I write a sort of memoir of my time on the island. Before and after this book I work on a series
of middle readers for 8 to 12-year-olds.
It is 2014. I am
fifty-seven years old. My first middle
reader came out in April. Elizabeth
leaves a lovely note on my blog. I look
her up again. She has published three middle readers.
I immediately buy her books and download them onto my Kindle.
Here’s my review for the first one:
*****************************************
Pretty Is by Elizabeth Holmes is one of a rare and rapidly
vanishing species of middle reader, a well-rounded story told in an age-appropriate
voice, a story with a plot and equally strong subplot. The characters are
finely drawn and utterly believable, and there’s action, suspense, and even a
moral that doesn’t sound preachy. And
yet, there are no vampires or werewolves, no epic battles, no fantasy worlds
and no alternative dystopian futures. How
could it possibly interesting?
Erin and Monica are sisters, but they couldn’t be more
different. Monica is one of those embarrassing older sisters who just doesn’t
fit in. And Erin wants desperately to fit in, to be surrounded by a large group
of friends. But the girls she used to be friends with are changing, and she’s
feeling left out. And Erin knows that’s only going to get worse, as next year
she will have to go to the same school with the embarrassing Monica, which
will, she is sure, destroy any chance she has left of winning her old friends
back. The summer starts out awfully, and goes downhill from there. No spoilers
here, but through a series of events and misadventures Erin learns that not
everyone has to be popular the same way, and even and older sister like Monica
can turn out to be a pretty good friend when the chips are down.
Holmes captures perfectly the angst of that age, those girls
on the cusp between adolescent and teen and feeling the pull of both worlds.
********************************************
I don’t mean this to sound as if I have been in competition
with Elizabeth Holmes my whole life.
What I’m trying to say is that I think it’s uncanny how two friends in
elementary school can go such separate paths and yet windup somehow connecting
at certain points all along the way.
She could always waterski better than me too.
Tuesday, August 20, 2013
So I’ve been reading . . .
a book about the New Bedford docks by Rory Nugent, and it
started me thinking about my time on Cuttyhunk Island again. Nugent’s book is called Down at the Docks, and it’s basically a history of the New Bedford
waterfront through the eyes of a number of different people.
Although Cuttyhunk:Life on the Rock was first person anecdotal, many of the
things I learned on the island I learned secondhand. Sometimes third or fourth hand. Way too many stories to put into one book,
and of course there are always stories within the stories. I’ve often been accused of telling a story by
starting with the stories within the stories within the stories, which some
people find much too time-consuming to listen to.
I realize it is difficult to believe people such as these exist. I have trouble believing it myself. I mean, if you don’t know the back story and
sometimes even the back story’s back story, how can you ever really understand
what went on? Of course, these are probably
the same people who skip to the back of the book to see how it ends. Heathens, I call them.
But I digress.
Astoundingly unusual for me, but it does happen.
Back to the point – those stories that don’t
get told. What happens to them?
I can’t answer that from a philosophical point of view. I didn’t take those classes in college.
In my world the stories that didn’t make it
into the book still get told to anyone who asks, some of them in conversation,
some in letters or emails. They used to
make their way into poems, often slipping in without my knowledge or
permission. That happens a lot with poems.
But I don’t write poetry anymore.
So where do the stories slip in? Right now they’re sliding into my new series
of middle readers. Not the way they are
told in my memoir, but pieced together like a quilt; a fragment from this
story, a snip of that memory…
photo A. Hinson![]() |
THE AVALON |
![]() |
WINTER HOUSE |
![]() |
THE ALLEN HOUSE |
(For example, in the book I'm working on now, 2nd in the Summerhood Island series, all three of these buildings have been morphed into one- The Sea Inn.)
A memoir should tell the truth, at least the truth as far as
the author can remember it.
But fiction is made of a different cloth. It can stretch in any direction, start out
with a name or a place and weave more names and places from other times and
other memories onto the beginning, into the middle, at the end, around the edges until you have something that resembles a
place you have known, or a person you have met The end result is not like
any place or anyone real. Sometimes it's a quilt. Sometimes it's just a raggedy mish-mash. This is
fiction. This is what I’m writing
now. And I have to admit that the
freedom to invent, and re-invent - is lovely.
Wednesday, June 26, 2013
Yes, it’s true . . .
We are way overdue for a recipe blog.
But
until a couple of days ago my recipes had been kidnapped and were being held hostage. And
the worst part is the kidnapper wouldn’t even contact me about a ransom.
And yes, it was irresponsible of me to send
my only copy of my recipe file out into the world alone, a print copy at that,
so faded and old as to be impossible to scan.
Mea culpa.
But who could know? And anyway, the crisis is over, and they
are back safe and sound, with a backup file to boot. And you still aren’t going
to get a recipe blog.
At least not this
time.
Because I promised on
Facebook that I’d write a quick book review. Even though Geoff Herbach’s I’m
with Stupid is a YA novel, and if I am going to put book reviews instead of
recipes or anything else on my blog I should
be writing reviews about middle readers since my first one (Coyote Summer, remember) comes out this
fall. Although I guess this is not really what you’d call a review. So maybe that’s ok.
I’m reading YA novels lately because I happened upon one
(Beautiful Music For Ugly Children) in the library and it stunned me. So I
wrote Kirstin Cronn-Mills (the author), and during our brief correspondence
she’s given me several other author’s names. And they have all been wonderful
and truly amazing. Amazing in that they
speak to such universal truths, to the real problems you face growing up and
the even realer problems you encounter trying to deal with them, that I found
myself saying yes, yes! (sometimes even aloud) as I read.
Because up until lately, you see, it’s only been Buffy the
Vampire Slayer.
And now you are really beginning to wonder. Buffy? Where on
earth is she going with this?
You know how some comics, like Ellen Degeneres, start out
with a topic and seem to wander all over and then suddenly Bam! - there they are back where they started having tied
everything up neatly?
Yeah.
Well, that’s probably not going to happen here. But
bear with me.
Buffy. The show that used vampires and demons and witches
and odd reptilian creatures to tell great stories that just happened to touch
on all of the problems high school kids face, sometimes providing solutions but
even when there wasn’t an easy solution you came away from the show feeling ok
about being different, or liking girls instead of boys, or not having a parent
around, or having scales and a tail because that one made you a natural for the
swim team?
Until recently, it seemed to me that with a few notable
exceptions, Buffy was it. And when YA literature started to become popular
again, it was full of dragons and vampires or it took place in the distant past
or future or on another world.
These people, though, this latest crop of writers, the
Kirstin Cronn-Mills’s and Geoff Herbachs and A.S. Hyatts and David Levithans,
just to name a few, they write these raw, powerful stories with problems like
the ones you had growing up, or people you knew had, and the endings aren’t
always all happy but there’s usually at least a few answers and a lot of hope
because that’s what you need when you are a teenager. These are the stories I read and my heart
tightens and then opens and oh, I wish I’d had these books when I was a
teenager because they are my life.
That’s what I’m With
Stupid did for me.
Take a kid who was bullied when younger, give him a terrible early memory he hasn't dealt with and a parent who's not really there for him. Throw in the fact that now he's a popular jock and a heck of a football player, partially because he's got this anger inside that he deals with by crushing the competition. How does he cope? Where is his life going? What happens when he decides to use his power for good instead of evil (sort of) ?
What happens is a piece of your life. Somewhere in this book, and others by the writers I've mentioned above, is a piece of your life. Doesn't matter who you are or what you were in high school. You're going to go - ""Wow. Yes." at some point.
Guaranteed.
So, no. not really a book review. But what I wanted to say.
And thank you, all of you YA writers out there.
Keep going.
Saturday, March 23, 2013
The best of intentions…
Well, I had every intention of writing a book review of my
friend Chris Grabenstein’s new middle grade novel collaboration with James
Patterson, I Funny. Because I liked it very much.
And I’ve always been interested in the
collaborative process. I’ve only had one
successful poetry collaboration, although I tried it with a number of people.
I was very curious to see if I could tell which parts of the
book were my friend Chris and which were Mr. Patterson, as I feel like I’ve
read enough of Chris’s work to have a handle on his voice. But it felt like a pretty seamless mesh of
styles, and except for a few phrases that were definitely Chris’s, the voice seemed
different from either of theirs alone.
But I digress.
As I
said, I was just getting ready to sit down and write a review when Chris posted
a review from a young man who has his own blog.
And after reading his review I felt anyone who wanted a sense of the
novel I Funny would be far better
served to simply follow this link. http://sammwak.wordpress.com/2013/03/19/jgb-2-0-i-funny/
This
kid is amazing. I can’t wait to read his
first novel, which I’m sure he will complete before finishing high school.
So maybe instead of reading and reviewing middle readers and
young adult books I’ll just stick to books about islands, the ocean, and things
of that sort, where I’m less likely to be one upped by a thirteen-year-old.
And don’t worry folks, this will count as my book review
post, and the next post will be a recipe.
Honest.
Here is a totally random picture that has nothing to do with middle school, really. Except it's a school. The Cuttyhunk schoolhouse, to be exact.
Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Mixing it up . . .
Well, the power was out again yesterday, but fortunately I had several hours
of power left in my laptop, so you get a post earlier than you normally might have.
I’m going to be switching things up a bit here in blog land, and along with remembrances
and recipes, you’ll be getting the occasional book review.
Why? Well, for one
thing, I write them. Books. Remember? In addition to my many other skills. And
I read them. Voraciously.
But mostly because it’s all about the story with me. Spoken,
written, visual, it’s all story. And it’s all important. Because that’s how we
learn, by story. We learn how to do concrete things, like cook. We learn how
life was in a place we love, back before we could live it ourselves. And
hopefully, we learn something about other people, and that way, about ourselves.
And hey, if you are wondering why I am reviewing some of the books I’m reviewing,
all I shall say for now is: patience. All will be revealed soon.
I love Juvenile and YA books. Always have. And now, with the
Hunger Games, and the Twilight series, it’s become ok to admit
it. Not that being slightly strange ever stopped me.
Chris Grabenstein writes
books, both adult and juvenile, that are great fun to read. And I’m not just
saying that because I knew him in college. Honest.
Chris Grabenstein’s The
Crossroads is his first YA/Juvenile novel, and I am almost as impressed
with it as I am with his adult mysteries.
Zack Jennings is a great character,
an 11-year-old boy who’s a bit of a nerd and a loner. To make matters worse, he
sees and hears things, things that are a lot like ghosts. His father’s
remarriage and their move to his hometown bring Zack up against a variety of
unsavory characters, both human and long-dead, and he is tapped to help right
some long-ago wrongs. In the process he gains self-confidence, learns to trust
himself, and takes us on a rollicking good ride in the process.
Read the book.
Give it to your kids.
They won’t even realize they’re learning something.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)